• The Bakerloop

    Read all about TfL's latest Superloop route here!

  • The Electric Takeover

    Keep up with all the electric buses with London Connected!

  • About Us!

    Get to know the team who have been fuelling the blogging community for 10 years.

  • Service changes

    Keep up-to-date with the Tenders page or visit us on Flickr for additional content.

  • Back On Track

    Expanding our coverage from the bus scene to the rail network.

  • Busy Bus Buzz

    Everyone's welcome to join and share their opinions on London's transport scene. All the news, views and more daily on our chatbox. Powered by Chatango

Showing posts with label Bus News. Show all posts

South takes on North

10 years of this blog, who knew we'd still be here all this time later! It's been a while since the last post, but here's one today. We are focussing on route 91 and its recent move to Go Ahead London operating obscurely out of Stockwell (SW). 



Yes, the route that runs between Trafalgar Square and Crouch End is being operated out of a garage in South London. There's a multitude of reasons for this, however the most widely acknowledged one is the crippling driver shortage at Northumberland Park (NP) up in North London (which was the garage which actually won the route) meant they were not in a position to take over the route. Stockwell garage isn't suffering as badly so were able to take the route on for now. 

Go Ahead are a new operator to this route, but if we look back into history the original plan where the 91 was meant to operate out of Northumberland Park isn't a completely new idea. The route is a relatively young one, starting operation in October 1992 running between Crouch End and Trafalgar Square via Holloway, Kings Cross, Euston, Russell Square and Aldwych. This is the same route that is in operation today. In 1992 when the route was introduced, it ran out of Holloway (HT) garage, at the time part of London Northern (Later MTL, and later Metroline). 1997 saw the route move to Northumberland Park (NP) under Capital City's (later First London) and in 2009 the route returned to operating from Holloway (HT) where it remained until Go Ahead took on the contract recently. 

© LondonBuses72
The previous two contracts at Metroline saw the route have an interesting allocation with it being allocated Enviro400s, then New Routemasters which were removed due to a variety of incidents on the route before using a mix of Wright Eclipse Gemini 3 and MCV EvoSeti bodied Volvo B5LH. The Go Ahead contract was won using existing hybrids, and these were soon after confirmed to be the unique EHVs that were previously allocated to the 135. Unique in the sense they are the only Enviro400 MMC bodied Volvo B5LHs in the Go Ahead fleet, and are part of only three batches in London completely. After being relieved from their duties on the 135, the EHVs initially made their way to Merton (AL) to provide cover for some grounded Optare MetroDecker EVs on the 200. They were then found on other routes at Merton before making their way to Stockwell. 

© EastLondoner
The Enviro400 MMC as a type are iconic to say the least, being present in almost every area of London, and you're never far from one. But I had special interest in doing the 91 on its first day at Go Ahead as the EHVs were the first MMCs that I rode. I made my way to Crouch Hill then grabbed a ride on the W7 to Crouch End broadway. I had to run to the bus stop to make my bus, which was going to be EHV8. Internally the bus felt like new, the refurbishment had very clearly been carried out to a very high standard. The ride itself was nothing out of the ordinary, we didn't have much traffic throughout the journey but this did have the negative effect of needing to stop three times to regulate the service. I wasn't too bothered about the regulation, but there was a large portion of people who got off my 91 that when the regulation announcement went off rushed off the bus and piled onto the 259 behind. Before I knew it we were along the Strand, stuck in traffic from the inevitable weekend closure of Whitehall due to a protest. 

While EHVs are to be the mainstay of the 91s allocation for the foreseeable future, Stockwell do have a variety of Hybrids available that can run the route. The first day itself saw WHV50, a Wright Eclipse Gemini 3 make an appearance on the route. 

© EastLondoner

I believe the eventual intention will be to move the 91 to Northumberland Park (NP) when the circumstances permit, so you may be limited in your time if you'd like to ride the route while it's operating out of Stockwell (SW). 


Go Ahead have been managing alright on the route so far (it's only been 2 days!), hopefully the operation remains consistent under their operation, and matches the standard set by their predecessor for the next 7 years!

The French Tower

It might be a stretch to ask whether anyone reading remembers the weird situation route W16 had in 2012 when it had three operators within the space of a month. Arriva lost the route to First, who then sold Northumberland Park (NP) to Go Ahead 4 weeks later. It's very rare any route has this happen, and naturally no route has matched that until a few weeks ago when route 414 became another route to go through three operators within the space of a month.




Abellio London up until the end of the 12th of November used to hold the contract to operate the 414, but Tower Transit took the helm on the 13th of November, although this wasn't to last for very long as RATP and Tower Transit had both announced a plan to merge operations into a company called RATP Dev Transit, and this would involve Westbourne Park moving over to a new company controlled majority by RATP, with Tower Transit retaining a minority shareholding. 


9487 seen on stand at Maida Hill
© EastLondoner

Route 414 is one of London's younger routes, only starting operation in November 2002 operating out of Westbourne Park (X) under First London, and running between Maida Hill, Elgin Avenue and Fulham, High Street, although buses would have to dead run to Putney Bridge Station from Fulham to stand. This arrangement was then changed so that buses would continue all the way to Putney Bridge in service from June 2002. January 2005 saw the northern terminus altered to be Maida Hill, Chippenham Gardens. No change then came until 2009 when tender saw Abellio London taking over the 414 out of their Battersea (QB) garage where it would spend the next 12 years. The tender in 2020 saw the route's tranche come up at a time when TfL were looking at many ways to save money, and it was decided that upon tender the route would be withdrawn between Marble Arch and Maida Hill, running only between Putney Bridge and Marble Arch. Tower Transit won the contract on tender using Alexander Dennis Enviro400 Hybrid buses previously allocated to route 23.


DNH39131 at Putney Bridge
© EastLondoner

Tower Transit took on the contract on the 13th of November, a couple of weeks earlier than planned in order to allow Abellio to take on route 63 at the same time. The route was cut back to Marble Arch on the same day, as planned. I went out a couple of weeks later on the 9th of December to take a look at how the route was doing, and to also try to do the route while still under Tower Transit operation. One thing that automatically stood out was the still the 'as new' state of the buses. Although they'd now undergone two refurbishments within the space of 10 years I'd not blame members of the public for thinking that these buses were completely brand new. Upon arrival at Putney Bridge I didn't need to wait long for a 414 to turn up. The journey itself was quite quick, with it just taking us over half an hour to make it to Marble Arch. Although while the journey was quick, it seemed the bus behind us had left very shortly after we had, and we managed to catch up the bus ahead of us. When we managed to reach Knightsbridge we were the middle bus in a triple bunching. Although these service control issues should hopefully be ironed out over the next couple of months as the controllers and drivers get used to the various challenges presented by the route. 


DNH39131 on stand at Marble Arch with Winter Wonderland in the background
© EastLondoner

The cut back to Marble Arch has made the 414 a very similar route to the 14, with all but three stops shared with the route now. At a time where TfL is extremely cash strapped, this obviously raises questions about the long term future of the route. Is a route that parallels another route almost end to end really worth the money? I'll leave that to you, the readers to decide. 


At the start of the post I did mention that RATP have since taken on route 414, and you're probably expecting the next part of the post to focus on their tenure on the route. However if you ventured out now you'd be hard pressed to find any sign of RATP on the 414, with the only giveaway being the legal lettering on the buses changing from Westbourne Park to Stamford Brook, which is the RATP head office. It's expected towards the start of next year that logos should start changing, alongside fleet codes which will see the "DNH" class codes replaced with "ADH" class codes alongside new numbers to fit in with the RATP system. 


DNH39122 seen on Park Lane
© EastLondoner

There's not much else to write about on this change, however the only thing that can be said is that this change sets the precedent for many future ones to come. It could be argued the 414 has got off very lightly with its cut back to Marble Arch, with rumours that some routes in the future could be at complete risk of withdrawal or much more severe cuts. Once upon a time the future for public transport and TfL looked very bright, however now the future looks to be a very bleak one indeed. 

It's been a long time

The title of this post has many meanings. Notably the fact it's been a long time since the last post on the blog, but it can also be applied to today's post directly. Routes 160 and 180 have returned to their traditional operating after many years away at others.




Routes 160 and 180 both operate in South-East London and have recently been taken over by Stagecoach, with the 160 coming from Arriva and the 180 coming from Go Ahead. The 160 now runs out of Catford (TL) garage and the 180 runs out of Plumstead (PD) garage, but while they're new contracts both routes have links to these garages going back many years. 


T315 seen at Catford Bridge
© EastLondoner

It makes sense to talk about the routes in numerical order. Starting off with the 160, the route today operates between Sidcup Station and Catford Bridge Station. It has a very long history dating back to 1938 operating out of Catford Garage (TL) and running between Catford, St Dunstans and Welling. It managed to remain unchanged all the way to 1985 when it was extended to Bexleyheath bus garage, although in 1989 it was cut It back from Bexleyheath to Eltham. 1996 saw the route extended from Eltham to Sidcup Station, forming the same route in operation today, although the Catford terminus changed from St Dunstans to Catford garage in 2000, before changing to Catford Bridge in 2006 when the route was lost on tender to Arriva's Dartford (DT) garage. The route ended up remaining at Dartford for the next 15 years, with the last 10 years seeing it allocated with Enviro400s. 

WVL357 and 327 at Cutty Sark
© EastLondoner
Moving on to route 180, a route a lot younger than the 160 which started operation in 1951 between Catford and Woolwich, operated out of Catford (TL) garage. The route was extended to Lower Sydenham in 1953. In 1963 the route was rerouted to Abbey Wood, 1981 saw a partial Plumstead (PD) allocation introduced with it becoming the full allocation in 1981, and in 1984 the route was cut back to Catford. In 1994 the route was cut back from Abbey Wood to Thamesmead East while also being cut back to Lewisham from the other end. It was in 1998 that Plumstead (PD) lost possession of the route, at the time to Harris Bus operating out of a garage in Belvedere (BV), which the route was subsequently extended to terminate at in 2002. BV garage eventually fell out of Harris Bus' hands, passing to direct TfL operation under the banner East Thames Buses before then passing onto Go Ahead London. The base was closed in 2017 and the route moved to terminate on a stand on Anderson Way, while the main allocation was moved to Morden Wharf. The loss of the garage terminus no doubt ended up coming full circle and Stagecoach took the route back to one of its old homes at Plumstead (PD). Its most recent contract at Go Ahead saw it allocated with Wright Eclipse Gemini 2 bodied Volvo B9TLs.

The tender announcement in November 2020 which announced the move of routes 160 and 180 to Stagecoach operation also mentioned that the routes would use brand new electric buses, although the 180 would have its fleet supplemented by some spare Enviro400 bodied E40H Hybrids which were already floating around the company. It was soon announced that the bus of choice was going to be the Alexander Dennis/BYD Enviro400 EV City which had become the standard choice for most London operators. Although for this reason, RATP, Abellio and Go Ahead also had a batch of the same type on order meaning Alexander Dennis was already very busy, coupled with the time required to install electric chargers at the garages it was no surprise to hear that the 160 and 180 route had to start their contracts off using existing buses before they could be replaced by electrics, much like the situation route 173 had to deal with a year ago. Stagecoach had some spare buses lying around, but nowhere near enough. An interesting chain of events led to Stagecoach loaning out Tower Transit's Wright Eclipse Gemini 3 buses that were previously allocated to route 328. 

The loaned buses started to arrive at Catford in advance of the 160 contract, which was to start two weeks before the 180, on the 18th of September. Prior to starting service the buses started to be run in on route 199 which terminates at Catford (TL) so it made it easy to swap the buses should any issues have arisen. They were given the numbers from 80112-80136, with the last three numbers being the same code that the buses had at tower transit (e.g 80112 is Tower Transit VH38112).

80127 seen at Canada Water on the 199
© EastLondoner

11001 seen at Catford Bridge
© EastLondoner
The 18th of September saw Stagecoach resume operation on the 160 after 15 years. As expected the allocation on the route was predominantly made up out of the loaned Tower Transit buses, although a few native Stagecoach Enviro400 MMCs also were on the route. I did go out on the first day to see how the route was doing, and truth be told I wish I didn't. Traffic within Catford, coupled with the fact that buses go back to Catford garage to change their drivers meant that the service was in tatters. I ended up waiting 45 minutes for a bus to turn up, this was despite many buses actually arrived but then ended up leaving out of service to go back to the garage to change their drivers. Eventually one did turn up, but by that point I didn't have the willpower to take a ride on the route and I just ended up taking a few photos and going home. 

Service since the first day has no doubt improved, it's not taken long for Stagecoach to realise the mistakes that took place on the first day, and adapt to the challenging conditions presented on the route. I'm sure over the next couple of weeks Stagecoach will adapt to the route and hopefully manage to provide a consistently good service similar to what was provided by Arriva at Dartford (DT) for the past 15 years.

80127 seen at Catford Bridge
© EastLondoner

12361 seen in Woolwich
© EastLondoner
Route 180s takeover plan was a bit different to that which had been executed on the 160, while there were loaned Tower Transit buses available for the route, the decision was taken to keep all the loaned buses at Catford (TL) and buses were transferred from Catford alongside other garages in the Stagecoach London empire to make up the numbers at Plumstead (PD), allowing the 180 to have a fully native Stagecoach allocation. The first day on the 2nd of October saw the allocation made up out of Alexander Dennis Enviro400 bodied E40H Hybrids, with a few Alexander Dennis Enviro400 MMC bodied E40Hs too, there were also a few loaned Smart Hybrids from West Ham (WH) on the route that had LED displays, although sadly I was unable to photograph one of these buses out. Operation on the 180 for the first day was a far better display than what was presented on the 160 two weeks prior, buses were generally running as expected and apart from a breakdown in Greenwich there wasn't too much out of the ordinary. 

12360 seen at Woolwich Arsenal
© EastLondoner
Go Ahead didn't set the bar particularly high on the 180, so hopefully we can safely say that the 180 is in better hands now and will be for the next 5 (or 7) years! When the electric buses start to arrive the 180 will still be allocated a few of these E40H buses, so you don't need to be in any rush to get them! Work is underway at Catford and Plumstead garages to ensure electric buses can be charged and hopefully it won't be too long until we see the brand new buses on the roads. Once the electric buses start to settle in on the 160 and 180, the buses that currently are found on the route should be released. With the loaned Tower Transit buses returning back to Tower Transit for the temporary contract on route 733 before settling down in their more permanent home on route 135 in the summer, while the plan for the buses on the 180 isn't particularly clear yet, although they should end up returning to their own garages of Leyton, West Ham and Catford. 

12344 seen at Lewisham
© EastLondoner

It's been announced by TfL that all of their new buses will be zero emission from now on, so electrics will be the norm! Although we could see some Hydrogen technology creeping in too. Routes 160 and 180 aren't the only routes waiting for their electrics, RATP in West London have a batch of over 100 waiting to enter service on routes 65, 281, 371, 290, X140, H9 and H10. Go Ahead have some arriving in the near future for route 132, Arriva are taking delivery of some for route 319 while Abellio are expecting some for their uptake of route 63 in November. This is very exciting time to be a bus enthusiast!

An Attack on the Tower

It's amazing to think that five years ago that we had a huge array of changes on the last day of April. We had the 345 going to Abellio, the 368 going to Arriva, the 35 and 40 going to Go Ahead while there were many new retains throughout London. It's often forgotten that during that time of huge change, among the changes were renewals to routes 28 and 328 by Tower Transit while they also started a new contract on the 69, which got advanced to February due to other circumstances and it ended up missing out on all the attention at the end of April it probably would have got. 


Two brand new electrics at Canning Town
© EastLondoner

5 years is either a short time, or a long time depending on how you view it. Things can change very quickly, but then it can also only feel like a day has passed. But I think Tower Transit would have wished otherwise. While they saw great success in 2016, retaining the 28 and 328 and winning the 69, 5 years later in 2021 it was a disastrous sequence of events for them. The summer of 2020 was certainly not a good time for them, losing two major contracts of routes 25 and 425, but a few weeks following the 425 loss they got further blows. A tender announced in July saw routes 28 and 69 both lost in a single round, with the 28 making a surprising move to RATP while the 69 was lost to Go Ahead from a new expanded base in Silvertown. Most notably, route 328 was missing from this announcement, prompting speculation about major alterations to the route, alongside a possible loss following on from the 28 and 69 awards. 4 long months later, the worst was confirmed for them, with an award in November seeing the 328 awarded to Metroline out of Cricklewood. 


This blow was not softened by the fact that the 28, 69 and 328 were all going to leave on the same day, the 1st of May 2021. While it was clear soon after the 328 award that the route would be heading to Cricklewood (W), there was some doubt over the 28 and 69 awards. RATP did have a garage not too far from the 28, in the form of Park Royal (RP), but the award was actually to RATP: London Sovereign, suggesting Edgware (BT) were the garage taking it on. Although a couple of months passed, and it was made public that the Original Tour depot (operated by RATP) in Wandsworth would be re-opening to TfL services following a reduction in tour buses following the pandemic. This garage however is no stranger to TfL services, operating the 337 many years ago for Arriva, when they owned the Original Tour garage under the code of WD. Although times have changed now, RATP are at the helm and with it comes a new code, JE for Jews Row. This wasn't the only new garage here though. Go Ahead had been on the lookout for new land in East London, following the news that half of River Road garage was being taken over by the council for redevelopment into a multi-purpose business centre. A new site was scouted out not far from the current Silvertown (SI) garage and would be home to the 69, there was some doubt initially over the garage opening on time, but that problem seems to have been overcome. 


VN37953 seen at Wandsworth
© EastLondoner

Starting off with route 28, a route which has a huge amount of history with Westbourne Park (X) was no doubt a major shock to many enthusiasts. The route's history goes back beyond 1934, with Westbourne Park (X) playing a role in the route's operation since 1938 when it had a partial allocation out of the garage as a Wandsworth Bridge - Golders Green route. A couple of years later, the route was extended further into Wandsworth Town Centre, forming a Wandsworth to Golders Green route which would last an extremely long time until 1999, when route 328 took over the section to Golders Green and the 28 was cut back to Harrow Road. Although in 2006 the route was extended from Harrow Road to Kensal Rise which formed the current route in operation today. In 2011, the route had to temporarily move out to a base in Park Royal (AS), although this was only temporary due to building works at Westbourne Park, the route returned there in 2017. The latest change of operator from Tower Transit to RATP marked the first time that the route would not have an allocation out of Westbourne Park (ignoring the phase AS had) since 1938. The last contract under Tower Transit saw the route allocated with Wright Eclipse Gemini 2 bodied B9TLs, supplemented by a few Wright Gemini 2 bodied DB300s. 

I went out a couple of days following the takeover to see how the 28 was doing under RATP. The new allocation was made up out of Wright Eclipse Gemini 2 bodied Volvo B5LH buses which were previously found on route 139 before that route was lost to Metroline in 2020. These buses were known to be in a notoriously poor state during their time on route 139, they had since undergone an extensive refurbishment. Although interestingly the refurbishment was carried out to different standards on each bus, some buses were fitted with completely new poles which can be easily identified with the new turquoise colour, while some buses continued with their orange poles which were resprayed. While initially confusing, it was later revealed that the refurbishment contract of the buses were split between two companies, Hants&Dorset and Thornton Brothers who each carried out refurbishments to a different standard. Both sets of refurbishments involved fitting of new moquettes to seats along with a deep interior clean. From my experience, the buses rode like new buses following their refurb. Certainly a major improvement from their previous state, I wouldn't even be surprised if people would mistake it for a completely new bus.

VH45119 is seen at Kensal Rise
© EastLondoner


VH45192 at Kensal Rise
©EastLondoner
The new allocation, as mentioned earlier comes out of Wandsworth (JE), which operates as an outstation for Stamford Brook (V), which as a result means any heavy maintenance is carried out there alongside any checks the buses will require. As a result buses may rotate between the two garages, and there's one allocated journey each day which goes back to Stamford Brook garage at the end of the day as opposed to Wandsworth to allow for routine maintenance. For this reason, some of Stamford Brook's own allocation will often appear on route 28. The day I did the route there were quite a few Wright Eclipse Gemini 3 buses out on the route. These buses are likely to appear on route 28 every couple of days should any of its own allocation require maintenance that results in it being out of action for a few days. Service on the route so far has been of a good standard, and all that's left is to hope that this good standard of service continues over the next 5, or maybe 7 years for this route!

VH38132 seen at Chelsea
© EastLondoner
As I mentioned, the lost section of the 28 to Golders Green was replaced by route 328 which was introduced in 1999, making this route a lot younger compared to its sister. It was introduced in 1999 as a Chelsea to Golders Green route and has remained as such ever since. The route was based at Westbourne Park (X) since inception, although it too did move out to the temporary site in Park Royal during the building works at Westbourne Park in 2011 before returning in 2017. Its most recent contract saw it allocated with Wright Eclipse Gemini 3 bodied Volvo B5LHs which were brought for a retained contract in 2016. These buses are similar to what it will eventually be allocated at Metroline, although currently they are on route 7 as that route waits for the introduction of Hydrogen buses. 

A loaned TT bus on the 328
© EastLondoner
However, due to a delay with the Hydrogen buses, Metroline found themselves in a sticky situation where the buses the intended to use on the route would not be ready. Due to spares not being available elsewhere in the fleet, the decision was taken to loan the buses from Tower Transit in order to start the service out of Cricklewood (W), with them gradually being replaced by the intended allocation of native Metroline Gemini 3s as the buses became available following the introduction of the Hydrogen buses. When this will happen at the moment is unclear, the pandemic has delayed the Hydrogen programme considerably and it could range from just a few weeks to many months until the buses are ready. Despite the loaned buses are the exact same allocation as Tower Transit, the move to Metroline did mean that native Metroline buses kept at Cricklewood (W) can appear on the route. Workings of native VWHs, TEHs and MMC TEHs have already happened on the route.

TEH2087 seen at Elgin Avenue
© EastLondoner

Arguably the most notable change of the trio was to that of route 69, which was the only route to get new buses. Unlike the 28 and 328, this route has managed to bounce around operators quite a bit. It still feels like yesterday when I wrote the post about route 69 making the move from Stagecoach to Tower Transit and it's already changed operator once again.

DN33653 seen at Walthamstow Central
© EastLondoner
Route 69 under Tower Transit was often a route that left a lot to be desired, bunching all over the place and unreliable service made the route very infamous among the local demographic. Therefore despite coming at a time when Tower Transit were suffering many route losses, it was probably a very welcome award. Fittingly, the move to Go Ahead was to bring brand new electric buses to the route, following on from the virtual electric buses that the route used to have a partial allocation of under Tower Transit. As expected, the preferred order was to be ADL BYD Enviro400 City EVs, a type that is becoming increasingly common in London. Currently as I type this the orderbook for that type alone exceeds 150 across all operators for London alone. Alongside the virtual electric buses, the majority allocation were standard Alexander Dennis Enviro400s. These buses have now been predominantly withdrawn from the TT fleet, although two are expected to remain at Lea Interchange (LI) for spares. 

DH38503 seen at Canning Town
© EastLondoner

Ee50 seen at Canning Town
© EastLondoner
The new garage operating route 69 was given the code DS, and is being referred to as Henley Road, presumably to avoid confusion with other garage a few units down. Prior to the announcement of River Road's downsizing, the intention was for Henley Road (DS) to actually be a fully electric operation, although that's no longer happening, planning documentation says the intention is for it to have a fully electric fleet in the future which makes it London's first purpose built garage for electric bus operation. This shows us increasingly where the future of London buses now lies, despite fully electric routes were once a pipe dream, they are now very much a reality and route 69 is just one addition to a growing number of routes. The buses themselves are not too different from the other electric BYD double deckers in London, although for some reason they have the middle seat at the rear of the lower deck blocked off. Other than that there's nothing special about the batch compared to other Go Ahead examples. 

Ee56 seen at Walthamstow Central
© EastLondoner

While these three routes all show promising future at their new operators, what does the future hold for Tower Transit? Every operator has its ups and downs, we only need to remind ourselves of the time when Stagecoach lost the 5, 15 and 115 all on the same day to Go Ahead just to bounce back a couple of years later taking on the 25 and 425 from Tower Transit. Arguably Tower Transit are having a far rougher patch, due to their small size. Routes 212, 444, 25, 425, 28, 328 and 69 have all been lost since the start of 2020, with only the C3 coming in as a result. Although route 414 will be making a move to Westbourne Park (X), it doesn't make up for the losses faced by the company. Routes 308 and 488 have been welcome retains for the company since the start of this year, however routes W15 and 13 are both due tender results over the next few weeks. Can they keep a hold of them and maybe win some additional work? Time will only tell. 

A Tale of Two Halves

It's rare that a route is the centre of attention as soon as a year after it last got some attention, however that's exactly what recently happened with the 306 which runs between Acton Vale and Fulham, Sands End Sainsburys. 



If you remember back a year ago, I wrote a post on some changes that took place in the Hammersmith and Acton areas where a couple of new routes were introduced in replacement for ones that had been cut back, one of these routes was route 306 which was introduced as a replacement for the lost sections of route 266 and 391. Now while route 266 has managed alright since it was cut back, route 391 hasn't been managing so well ever since it was shortened and TfL have made further changes to the route in the form of a merger with route 110. At the same time, route 306 has also been tendered on a brand new 5 year contract with potential for a 2 year extension and Metroline came out victorious for that route. 


Usually with routes that change operator I give you a bit of background to the route, talking about its history and how it evolved over time. However with the 306 only being a year old there isn't much to talk about, the most I can do is point you in the direction of this post where I covered the introduction of the route. It might be a bit weird, a route changing operator a year after it was introduced although I assure you there's a really good reason for that. Route 306's introduction resulted in a hefty cut to the 391 last year, and the cut was big enough to a point RATP would require some compensation. Therefore TfL decided to split the 391 contract into two and hence RATP took over the 306 under the terms of the old 391 contract, but as a result the new 306 shared the same contract end date as the 391 which happens to have been this December when both 306 and 391 were put up for tender. 


As I already mentioned, Metroline were the winners of the route with RATP unable to retain the route when it was put out for tender. When the route was awarded it was mysteriously awarded with its bus type "To be confirmed" which led to speculation about what the route would end up using. Eventually it was confirmed that the buses that would operate the route were actually the buses that were previously allocated to route 212 under Tower Transit operation (VH38101-VH38111), these were coded VWH2697-VWH2702. Prior to their entry into service they were given a refurbishment and temporarily put to work at Uxbridge (UX) as school extras before making their way down to Brentford (AH) where route 306 was planned to operate out of. 


My ability to go out and cover the 306 change was put short by two separate lockdowns due to the Covid pandemic, so by the time I managed to cover the 306 it was April by which point Metroline have been operating the route for 5 months. I went out on the 5th of April, a couple of days after non-essential travel was allowed once again. Having rode the 306 from Acton Vale to Hammersmith last time I covered the route, this time I opted to cover the route from Hammersmith Bus Station to Sands End Sainsburys. While I was waiting for the bus I did see VWH2705 pass me heading towards Acton Vale which is illustrated in the picture on the right. Shortly after that bus passed my ride arrived in the form of VWH2707, which was one of the 15reg examples on the route. The 306 leaving Hammersmith follows the previous 391 route heading through Kensington Olympia and then through Fulham Broadway before reaching Sands End Sainsburys via Imperial Wharf station. 

The interior remains largely unchanged
The buses themselves aren't too different as to how they were found on the 212, even going so far as to still having the same moquette design, although new upholstery was put in during the refurbishment process, probably a decision by Metroline as their blue moquette would have probably clashed internally with the green theme of Tower Transit's old interior. So far on this route, service seems to have been provided to an acceptable standard. Although currently roadworks taking place at Fulham are affecting the route, although from my experience today I didn't find any major issues. My bus came at the correct time, and when I took a look on LVF the route was certainly coping a lot better than some other routes in the area were. 

Since its introduction in 2019, the route seems to be a tale of two halves. Its terminal point of Acton Vale has proved to be quite controversial. Route 266 that it replaced along that section would often pick up passengers from Acton High Street, but as the 306 only starts at Acton Vale single decker route 218 has to bear the brunt of the work here. But then the other half, from Hammersmith to Fulham has no doubt thrived under the presence of double deckers, my journey today had healthy loads despite were were just starting to come out of a lockdown, you can tell that the extra deck the 306 carries as opposed to the previously single deck 391 is very much appreciated among the locals. As for the new link beyond Hammersmith to Acton, it is yet to be seen how well that has taken off. When I boarded the bus today at Hammersmith a large number of people alighted before a decent number of people boarded, suggesting that this route is effectively two routes operating as one. Although now that lockdown is over, we will be able to see if people are starting to warm up to the new link beyond Hammersmith.




All that's left to say now is that hopefully Metroline keep up the standard they have shown so far on the 306 for the next 5, or maybe 7 years!

I know lately the blog has been quiet, the lockdown has meant we have been unable to travel outside and cover the latest changes. But now it's been lifted rest assured we will try out best to cover most of the changes we missed and to cover the ones in line next. In the meantime remember to keep up with all the latest changes on the London Bus Scene on the tenders page. Also take a look at our Twitter feed to keep up with the latest news on the bus scene.

All photos on this post are © EastLondoner. Please do not use without Permission

Letting Go

33 years is a long time, isn't it? However things cannot remain the same forever, change is good and change will eventually need to come for many things. Route 173, being one of Arriva's longest standing routes has just made the move from Arriva at Barking (DX) to Stagecoach at Barking (BK)


T73 seen in Barking on route 173
© EastLondoner

Depending on where you live, and what groups online you are a part of and what website you visit, you have either heard of route 173 endless times over the past few months or you've not heard about the route at all. The route runs between Beckton Station and King George Hospital in East London and is known for having a good portion of its route running down the A13 road, one of London's busiest and most troublesome roads. 


Route 173 started operation in 1973, however was quite a different route to what it is today running between Canning Town and Becontree Heath via Dagenham Heathway and Newham Way, with peak hour extensions continuing the few stops ahead to Poplar from Canning Town. In 1979, the route was extended from Canning Town to Stratford, running via West Ham Station. In 1983, the portion where the route used Newham Way after Canning Town was altered so that the 173 would run via Asda in Beckton to provide some better links to shoppers. In June 1993 the route was extended from Becontree Heath to Little Heath via Chadwell Heath. A few months later in September 1993 the route was cut short from Stratford to Beckton, with the lost section being partially replaced by route 473 forming the 173 as we know it today. An extension in the late 90s saw the route extended the extra stop from Little Heath to King George's Hospital. 


Two Enviro400s on the 173 stand at Beckton
© EastLondoner

So the obvious question is what makes the 173 change special? It just seems like a normal route end of the day. However once we look at the heritage of Arriva London, what is now London's second largest operator had quite humble beginnings in the capital. In the late 1980s, the 173 was operated by a small company called Grey-Green, with their base in Barking along Ripple Road which is DX garage today. Grey Green was purchased by the Cowie Group in their first step to becoming a London operator, making the 173 their first route. The Cowie Group is what was later rebranded as Arriva, the same Arriva that we know today. At the time I write this post, Arriva has a PVR of 1410, making it London's second biggest operator, the same operator who purchased route 173 as their first route. Up until the recent tender change route 173 had run out of DX garage since 1987 making it 33 years of operating there which is a really long time, probably longer than the lifespan so far of some of you reading this.


Some Wright Gemini 2 buses at Beckton
© EastLondoner

The past 5 years of the 173s operation has had its ups and downs to say the least, when the contract was renewed last time I wrote about the upgrade of the route to double decker on this blog. The allocation was made up out of Enviro400s which were initially brought for the 38s conversion from bendybus operation in 2009, however these got supplemented with a few Wright Gemini 2 bodied DB300 buses when route 175 was won in 2017 by Arriva alongside the sporadic appearances of Enviro200s the route certainly had an interesting allocation. However towards the end of the contract the allocated Enviro400 buses started to feel extremely tired and worn down while the Wright Gemini 2 buses that would appear were just too slow to be suitable for a route that has a decent portion at 50mph speed limits. Towards the end of the contract the prospect of a brand new allocation looming was becoming more and more attractive. 

The loaned buses being prepared for takeover
© EastLondoner
Due to the Coronavirus Pandemic of 2020, the intended electric buses due for the route were going to arrive late as the factories were all impacted by the lockdown that was imposed. This left Stagecoach in a scramble to find suitable buses to run the 173 with in the meantime. Many operators in this case would usually just hire buses from the incumbent operator, as has been the case with previous changes such as route 285 and K1, but instead Stagecoach hired buses that RATP had spare. The reason for this is anyone's guess as the reason hasn't been made public, although judging by the state of some of the Arriva Enviro400s it was certainly good news to hear that they wouldn't be sticking around on the route. The buses that were hired ranged from ADE40410-17, ADE40425 and ADE40455-ADE40461. Prior to entering service on the 173 the buses were given their new numbers, in the 80*** range alongside temporary logos and new BK blinds. 

Luckily as I live on the route, it didn't take me much effort to go and cover the service on the first day. My first bus was actually a native Stagecoach bus in the form of 19847, which was drafted in from Leyton (T) to help out. The ride wasn't anything too special, apart from the bus feeling like a completely new vehicle compared to the 173s old allocation with Arriva which left a lot to be desired. 
 
80413 seen at King George Hospital
© EastLondoner

80425 and another Enviro400 at Beckton
© EastLondoner
When my bus reached King George Hospital the driver wasted no time in switching the blinds and dead running the bus back to the garage. A quick look at the Stagecoach schedule shows that the 173 has quite an interesting changeover arrangement. Due to the 173s slightly C shaped nature, both Beckton Bus Station and King George Hospital aren't particularly far from Barking (BK) garage, so at times of day (and all day during weekends), buses run back to the garage for their changeovers from both ends. As a result the route can look incredibly unbalanced on tracking apps due to the constant turnover of buses running the route. During the week this arrangement is still in place for some journeys, however live changeovers also take place at the Lodge Avenue flyover (which is the same place they happened when Arriva used to operate the route). These changeovers are eventually expected to move to Becontree Heath when the drivers rest facility is modified there. 

Euro5 Voith Enviro400s were never going to be the most enjoyable buses down the A13, so later on in the day I tried out a loaned RATP bus, my bus was going to be ADE40456, or 80456 as it was now numbered. This bus was a lot more enjoyable than the existing Stagecoach stock that it was working alongside and was in a really good condition, so thumbs up to RATP for that! Before I knew it I was home. Since the first day I've used the 173 quite frequently, sampling a variety of the buses on loan from RATP and many are in excellent condition, although 80412 does make a weird whining noise. Regardless it's quite easy to say that the temporary allocation of the 173, despite being 8 years old is a massive upgrade to the buses that were previously used on the route. 

10136 on stand at Beckton Bus Station
© EastLondoner

Stagecoach have had the 173 for over a month now, and have brought a noticeable step forward for the route. While Arriva had quite a lot of history with the route, service was quite poor and the buses it used were dreadful. With Stagecoach a noticeable improvement in service is already visible alongside the obvious improvement in the quality of buses operating the route - even if they are temporary cast offs! 

Electric buses have started arriving for route 174, and the buses for route 173 are expected to follow suite. Barking (BK) garage have their chargers installed now so keep an eye on the blog for a post covering the new electrics in East London soon!

First, but also the last?

Arriva have been having quite a beating as of late in Tenders, losing quite a few routes. However a silver lining for them has seen the gain of route 202 out of Norwood garage (N) from Go Ahead London at Croydon (C). 


WHV73 on stand at Blackheath
© EastLondoner
The 202 initially started operation in 1991 as a single decker route, running between Crystal Palace and Blackheath via Sydenham, Catford, Lee and Blackheath Village. Those of you familiar with the route will have already realised that this is the same route which is followed today, making it one of the few routes which haven't changed much through their existence. When the route was initially introduced, it was operated by Stagecoach out of Catford (TL), however a tender change in 2008 saw Metrobus take over the route running it out of their Croydon base (C). The contract renewal in 2015 gave the route a much needed double decker conversion with some brand new Wright Eclipse Gemini 3 buses. 

Two buses stand at Blackheath
© EastLondoner
The tender award towards the end of 2019 resulted in Arriva winning the contract to the route running out of Norwood with brand new Hybrid buses being introduced, an award many people didn't see coming. This did throw up some interesting questions though, as Arriva's preferred manufacturer for hybrid double decker buses, Wright, had just fallen into administration and any delivery and fulfilment of orders would have been in doubt. However, near the start of 2020, it was announced that Alexander Dennis were the company who would be getting the order with them delivering brand new Enviro400 MMC bodied E40H buses, the first of the type for Arriva London. Although, they do have E40H buses already, in the form of E40H Citys based at Brixton (BN) on the 133 and 333 alongside Ash Grove (AE) who operate them on the 78. Sadly, while Arriva may have dodged a bullet by not ordering with Wright, they couldn't avoid the one caused by the Coronavirus pandemic where all buses were delayed. However, luckily for Arriva, fellow route 405 also had a batch of E40Hs due, so the buses were conveniently swapped around to allow the 202 to have a full E40H allocation from the first day. 

Since the changeover in September, I've used the route a few times alongside the buses. Starting off with the positive aspect the buses are amazing, a part of me hopes that Arriva had been forced away from Wright a lot sooner. The interior suits the buses well and so far they have been well kept, albeit it's only been a month. While Arriva do have E40H Citys in the fleet, these buses come with the standard TfL interior with red seats and gold poles. Arriva's own interior with blue seats and ivory poles gives the already nice and spacious MMC interior an even more spacious feel, making it a really nice ride from a passenger's perspective. Oh, and of course there's USB ports at most seats as is standard on London's buses these days. So far the allocation of the route has been solidly E40H MMC, but a few strays of Wright Eclipse Gemini 3 buses have happened from batches kept at Norwood for other routes. I imagine these will eventually start to become common as more of the fleet is reblinded. 

HV398 seen at Blackheath
© EastLondoner

I did say earlier that talking about the buses would be the positive aspect, there sadly has been a negative aspect as well to these changes. Route 202 while initially may come across as a small suburban route does have a substantial portion running along the A205 between Lee and Catford. This section is often filled with traffic in the peaks and can cause a headache for controllers and as a result the service quality has seen a drop since the route left Go Ahead. Initial days saw almost all of the northbound service turned to Blackheath Village during the evening peak, however it's calmed down a lot now although far from perfect, showing that with a few more months Arriva are likely to get the hang of this challenging route and provide a good quality service to match the amazing standard of the buses. 

A side view of HT17 at Blackheath Station
© EastLondoner

With the increasing drive to get London's bus fleet closer towards zero emission, it's unknown whether Hybrids will soon be confined to the history books. Since the delivery of these buses, London for the first time in years has no diesel powered buses on order from any manufacturer. While routes 202 and 405 make up the first batch of Arriva's Enviro400 MMCs for London, they could also very well form the last batch of them.